Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sonny Santos's avatar

Perhaps not a perfect analogy, but this reminds me of when high-level languages like C and BASIC emerged to abtract away raw assembly code and bit manipulation. High-level languages dramatically broadened who could write software and increased developer throughput by tenfold.

My professors insisted that we still learn assembly and understand the bits. Some did, and used that knowledge to optimize memory and CPU usage, precision control, and reduce overhead to fit in what little memory was available.

Of course, there's a marked difference between abstraction and agency. Still, my professors were right about assembly back then, and the principle holds today: the best users of high-level abstractions are always the people who understand what happens underneath when those abstractions fail.

Pharoah's avatar

Reading the article made me think about Michael Faraday.

It may be that some of us, no matter how hard we try, will never realistically be able to achieve the kind of proficiency in building using code. It's a particular kind of skill, I think.

Faraday had little understanding of advanced mathematics, yet he became a pivotal figure in advancing our understanding of physics - I think it's because he had an intuitive understanding of nature. He needed a Maxwell to describe his work mathematically. What if Faraday had an LLM? Would that have made him any less of a towering figure?

I guess, for the rest of us mere mortals, we should learn as much as we can about codes (and mathematics!). But perhaps the value comes from knowing what is worth building and doing it as best as we can.

PS: Usually, I don't comment much. But the article was thought provoking. Thanks Gary.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?